Showing posts with label books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

In Mean Country

Battleborn
Claire Vaye Watkins
Riverhead Books, 2012 (283 pages)
ISBN: 978-1-59448-825-2

In Mean Country
by Mark Hummel

Claire Vaye Watkins writes as if she scratches her stories from the grit and mining detritus of the Nevada desert she grew up in, then transforms the elemental by gathering language as rich and as natural as the sand or minerals found there like an alchemist. The work is as layered as the often brutal human history of the region, a history she both draws upon and to which she will surely add her own narrative. And like the harsh landscapes and histories that everywhere informs these brilliant stories,  when you peer long enough, closely enough, at what seems an empty, heartless place, you not only see its unforgiving beauty within the parched hills and among the tailings castaway after decades of exploitation, you also find glitter among the hardscape, the glint of silver and gold. Like the characters in her story collection Battleborn, the truths Watkins unearths require strong stomachs and strong wills to digest but reward the reader with sparkling prose, hard but achingly accurate portraits of unforgettable characters, and gemstones of hope among the chaos of despair and interior pain.

They are difficult portraits, not for the faint of heart. In Battleborn you pass time among prostitutes and failed prospectors, with the progeny of Manson’s Helter Skelter crew and with high school pizza makers seeking identity through sexual awakening in a Vegas hotel room with strangers. We meet a narrator so lost he writes life-revealing letters to a stranger whose address he found among the remains of an apparent desert car accident. Remarkably, however, Watkins is uncanny at not just allowing unfamiliar readers an introduction to such roughened and often weathered characters, within them she nearly always helps us also see vulnerability, sorrow, love, desire, and yes, hope.

Savagely gifted, Watkins can create an odd kind of beauty even in horror and ugliness like these lines describing a dying peacock, a bird that has become one of the last and most unlikely objects of affection for an aging, gay whorehouse manager, facing rejection from a beautiful, lost young tourist from Italy in “The Past Perfect, The Past Continuous”:

                For an instant the air is filled with the report of the sternum snapping. Michele’s never
                seen a bird like this. The snowy feathers redden as blood wells up around the prongs.
                He feels the give of the meat as he plies the rake from the bird’s breast.

Or consider this movement from wanted violence to heartache and defeat in “Man-O-War”, a story where a lonely old divorcee thinks he finds, then loses, new attachment to another:

                The truck pulled away and began its descent to the bald floor of the valley. Milo resumed
                her barking. Harris told her to shut up, but she went on. Rhythmic, piercing, incessant. The
                old man had never heard anything so clearly. He felt a steady holy pressure building in him,
                like a vein of water running down his middle was freezing and would split his body in two.
                He lunged at the dog. He wanted ore to skull. He wanted his shoulder burning, his hand
                numb. He wanted holes that had been her ear and eye growing wider, becoming one, bone
                crumbling in on itself like the walls of a canyon carved by a river. He wanted wanted wanted.

The stories are like a series of accident scenes from which you cannot look away. But more than that, you don’t want to look away. Like with Harris and this sudden urge for violence against his only companion, the only thing left alive in his life alone in the desert above an empty lake bed, we understand the deep, scouring loneliness that manifests itself in this moment when another person, a stranger requiring care, is taken away from him and he has realized that this target of his misplaced affection is as wounded as he.

Reviews like those offered by no less potent a voice in short fiction than Joy Williams have likened Watkins to Joan Didion for her mature management of economy and sharpness of prose, and it is an apt comparison, for Watkins proves to understand not only the power and beauty of the perfectly chosen word or phrase, she demonstrates that she understands what not to say just as keenly. It is often the sparseness of these stories that is most striking, the space that allows a focus on just how lonely and lost so many of these characters are. In such characters, Watkins echoes other writers of the literary West with her presentation of trailer parks and one room casinos and unforgiving apartment complexes, landscapes passed over and cityscapes better left unvisited, places and people that recall Raymond Carver most closely, with a nod to Nathanael West, or moved East, characters that could inhabit an Andre Dubus story. Like those writers and like Didion, her prose is precise, sometimes nearly deceiving by feeling so understated and matter of fact. Yet, just when you are brought closest to the story by its accuracy of detail or directness of dialogue, she’ll leave you abruptly panting at the beauty of a turned phrase or graceful description. The details are precise and revealing, the stories nuanced and extraordinarily mature in their vision. Here for example, the narrator of “Graceland”, trying to find her bearings six months after her mother has committed suicide, reflects on her boyfriend’s unfaltering patience:

                After Peter and I have sex there is some smallness in me that wants to turn to him
                and ask, In your professional estimation as a scientist, how long can a relationship
                be sustained on pity and anthropomorphism and a postcard on the fridge?

                But there is such bigness in him that he would say, As long as it takes.


This remarkable ten story collection certainly has not gone without notice and praise, winning the Story Prize for 2012 by gaining the nod over collections by Junot Diaz and Dan Choan, and listed by the San Francisco Chronicle as one of the best books of that year, still, like most story collections and indeed like most literary writers, Watkins has not gathered the readership she deserves. Not all readers love collections. But this one offers the very best the short form can accomplish, presenting stories that read with the breadth that seem ready for expansion into novels yet that, every time, prove fulfilling and complete as they stand. You will not want to seek out the real-life equivalents of these characters to pass your leisure among but you will cherish the way that meeting them in fiction can transform your vision of your own fears of failed life ventures and castings of hope.

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Finding Substitutions for Loss

A Constellation of Vital Phenomena
Anthony Marra
Hogarth 2013 (379 pages)
ISBN #978-0-7704-3640-7



  
Finding Substitutions for Loss
by Mark Hummel

A failed doctor, unable to mend the ailing, sketches portraits of refugees fleeing war and paints life-sized painted plywood cutouts of those disappeared from his village. A refugee, conscripted into prostitution and forced heroin addiction, now returned to the place and the war from which she sought refuge, draws the cityscape over a curtained window of buildings now missing or ravaged by bombs. A father, who has lost his fingers in pointless, cruel interrogation, turns to his child to become his hands. Another doctor severs the limbs of landmine victims with the ease of lopping branches from trees, substituting in her efficiency the loss of a disappeared sister and the life of comfort and love she could have had in London. A father saves his voice and his love for the son he has created by love rather than the one created by blood, this now unwanted son who informs on their neighbors. A Constellation of Vital Phenomena, the title itself a substitute for the definition of life according to an aged medical text, creates brilliant layers of substitutions of love for a populace slowly being exterminated by hate. Over-arching the entire novel is another substitution—those filling the role of parents and caregivers for others stripped from their families by an illogical and chaotic war—acting out a tale brought down from the Bible and the Koran.


Set inside a layered rendering of the wars and their aftermaths that destroyed Chechnya from 1994 to 2004, Marra takes the reader into terrain—historical, literal, and political—that we should be embarrassed for not knowing. Long-listed for the National Book Award and short-listed by countless “best of” lists of 2013 fiction, A Constellation of Vital Phenomena is a literary debut worth every piece of praise it has garnered. So adroitly does the novel manage complex layers of time and overlapping events, a reader would never imagine this is Anthony Marra’s first novel. Certainly his background demonstrates all the vestiges of America’s literary incubators—a degree from the Iowa Writer’s Workshop and a Stegner Fellowship at Stanford—but one remains shocked at the knowledge Marra demonstrates of the wars that have razed Chechnya or the control he exerts over satisfyingly complex and self-contradictory characters or the maturity of recognition present in this parent story of caring for a variety of displaced orphans. Perhaps most impressive is how beautiful Marra is able to depict images and actions that should be so ugly; instead he salvages beauty from the very language he employs and the precise details he uses. If you are a reader of traditional print books because you are forever writing in the margins, your margins of this book will be filled to overflowing if only marking the moments of breathtaking and exacting prose. Everywhere Marra shows us the dignity and the beauty of people we might otherwise dismiss as inept, or as cold, those we might regard as without meaning or those already destroyed by the cruelty around them. If this is where Anthony Marra starts his career, it is difficult to imagine and wonderful to anticipate the books he will write in his future.

Monday, February 24, 2014

A Sign of the Times

Late last week, bestselling novelist James Patterson donated a million dollars to independent bookstores. The donation will go to selected bookstores without strings, though it will work for most as a kind of grant that will allow special programming, such as developing a children's author series, creating a book mobile kind of outreach, and the like. It is, simply put, a generous and wonderful gift. Patterson didn't have to do it.

Patterson has said that the future of American literature would be lost without independent booksellers. That statement may be a bit grandiose, for wherever writers ultimately sell their work, they will produce work and the there will be readers for that work, even if that segment of the population continues to shrink. However, his heart is in the right place. And the loss of independent booksellers will be extraordinarily sad and something vital for books, and for local communities, will be lost. Like Patterson, I am a fan of local independent booksellers, a fan of all things local really, but like most, I would be lying if I said I spend my book money exclusively with my local bookstore. And in the interest of full disclosure, my own work must be ordered by local booksellers, and it, absent a few fiery, risk-taking bookstore owners, will likely never be stocked on their shelves, for as an independent author, my fate, for better or worse, is mostly tied to eBooks and to print books sold via giants like Amazon. And this makes me incredibly sad. But my own situation points to some of the complications of current publishing and distribution streams, and the the Patterson donation offers strange evidence of much about the current book climate.

This situation is rife with irony and with telling details. (And while I am offering disclosures, I must admit that I have never read Patterson. What he writes simply isn't in keeping with what I look for in fiction. That's not a statement of elitism but one of personal taste. Indeed, writers like myself are in odd predicaments when it comes to big time bestsellers like Patterson, for publisher's devotion to such writers has eviscerated the mid-list among the Big 5, but at the same moment, writers like Patterson make so much money for their publishers that they essentially "carry" the mid-list writers publishers do still publish.) That last statement suggest one of the first ironies this news points towards. Here's another: while a percentage of Patterson's sales flow through independent booksellers, it's a tiny portion of his sales, for the Patterson brand is a billion dollar business. He cranks out more titles per year than is humanly possible, truly creating some kind of factory style of novel production for all ages and all markets, with YA titles alongside adult fiction with more than just a few titles that acknowledge writing partners. Patterson is a rare phenomena, an industrial sized writer who lands multiple titles on the bestseller list every year. His work is available in every format--eBook, audio, hardcover, large print, multiple languages, trade paperback and mass-market paperback and is sold everywhere--at the behemoths like Amazon and other Internet-based retailers, at Costco, at Walmart, in used bookstores and in independents, among others. Varying sources place Patterson's net worth at somewhere between $150 and $310 million. All this points to something else about the generosity of his donation--it must be genuine in its intent, for he has no need to maintain political capital with independent booksellers. Patterson is unique in his ability to try and sustain a foot in two worlds--in the shifting publishing climate of digital books and Internet sales, and in the old, charming world of small bookstores run by dedicated, knowledgeable bibliophiles. The book world is changing so fast most cannot keep up. Patterson sees steady sales growth because he has been very successful in the publishing new world even as he makes a gift to one element of the publishing old world.

Note something immediately obvious. We haven't exactly heard the story of publishers, let alone HIS publisher stepping up and matching his donation. This, despite that his titles have sold more than $1.5 billion in the US alone. Patterson is iconic, for he represents the sort of author in which both publishers and big box book retailers have placed all their eggs (and most of their marketing dollars). Yet this kind of focused investment of capital and marketing is much of what shifted the ground of the publishing industry, stripping the mid-list, and ultimately, once coupled with emergent technologies like digital publishing, Internet sales, and new distribution channels, paved the way for the book market that today is largely being shaped by Amazon. I've already disclosed my own dependencies on Amazon, and there is no accusation here towards Patterson, rather, Patterson has simply proven a genius at employing the market forces that exist and the forces of the modern market have combined to threaten independent booksellers with extinction.

Like most great entrepreneurs, the best of independent bookstore owners have proven crafty and resilient, and those that continue to survive have learned that they must own the niche markets, including selling the titles of small presses (to where many mid-list authors have fled), focusing more on children's books, developing community outreach, coupling with other enterprise (like coffee), and consistently outperforming all other book retailers with superior customer service. They will have to continue to be creative, including doing ever more to best represent authors local to their region, continuing to be the hub for writer and book events, developing (if financially possible) in-store print on demand ability, offering consignment sales for indie-publishers, and generally sustaining religious fervor for their support among the literati, the intellectuals, and the super-readers in their communities. There is little doubt that independent booksellers who gain direct benefit from Patterson's gift will put it to imaginative and productive use. Still, we have to ask, what does it say about the intellectual (and capitalistic) climate in the US when small business owners need donations to keep their doors open?

I do hope the independent bookstore will not just survive but will thrive. I want that. I want to sit among their selves in comfy chairs and read. I want to know that my money is going back into the community I live. But I fear, as my own publishing relationship with independents reflects, that we are living in the midst of change that will prove permanent. Indeed, with many reports that the giant Barnes & Noble may go the way of Borders, much of purchasing books has already changed. Perhaps there will be life in the niche markets for independents, but like schools, writers, small presses, and girl scouts, there will be more gifts and more bake sales needed to help make that happen.

I'll likely not read Patterson, but I certainly applaud his gift.

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

Jennifer Egan Interview/Chat Session at Goodreads

For members of Goodreads, Pulitzer Prize winner Jennifer Egan graciously took reader questions in a video chatroom session on August 2nd 2011: http://www.goodreads.com/topic/video_chat/9

Friday, June 17, 2011

Book Recommendation: Volt by Alan Heathcock

Volt, Alan Heathcock's debut collection of stories is one of those books that makes you celebrate the continued existence of small presses.  Volt is a 2011 release from Graywolf Press, and sadly, as a debut collection, it is one of those books likely passed over by the large houses, and as a result, unnoticed by most readers despite outstanding reviews.  That Mr. Heathcock will not benefit from a larger marketing budget and greater distribution is a shame, for it is a collection that should be on every one's "best of" lists for 2011.  Graywolf has a long history of championing such fine writers, and they've got a winner here.  It is a stunning collection of stories linked by a common setting and frequently featuring common characters.  The collections are a study in realism done right.  All may not want to face that characters who so often demonstrate such profound loss and sadness such as these, but we would be missing a glimpse at our own towns and our own lives if we turned from such realism.

Heathcock is masterful at offering more plot than many contemporary literary writers without sacrificing anything in depth of character or lyricism of language.  We may turn away in our own lives from characters such as those who people Volt, but we will be wiser and more compassionate if we face them.  It is a fairly thin collection with only seven stories, and you will be tempted to read the book straight through in one sitting, but you will fight that urge only because you want to savor each story.  Indeed the stories are likely to haunt your dreams.  Heathcock writes beautifully.  He  develops realistic characters who offer complexity and depth.  He is the sort of writer who other writers will be copying sentences from in journals just to study craft, and yet you would hardly know it, for the pace of the stories keeps the reader bolting through them and the grip of the narrative carries such truth that most readers will have to stop once and again to remember how beautifully Heathcock writes.


Alan Heathcock
 Heathcock also reveals himself as one of the first and certainly the most dexterous writers to begin and face the homecoming realities for some veterans returning from Afghanistan and Iraq.  Largely those lives have been ignored, not just in our newspapers but in our novels.  It is not exactly a pretty picture of these lives as painted here, but I suspect, at least for many, it is an accurate one.  Such lives are not the focus of the collection but they seem to inform it throughout and certainly they echo its themes of morality and mortality, of guilt and shame, of bravery and persistence.  Heathcock's deftness in managing such complicated themes with understatement and his ability to rescue lives that we might dismiss is reminiscent of another debut writer I have championed--Josh Weil (The New Valley) and both writers will rightfully earn comparisons to the early novels of Cormac McCarthy and to Andre Dubus (both II and III).

Support a debut writer while supporting a small press and buy Volt.  While you are at it, buy one or two more copies for friends.  They will thank you.  And you will thank yourself for helping make possible more books from this fine writer in the future.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Borders Bankruptcy

As industry experts have been suggesting for months, Borders recently filled for bankruptcy.  How this goes, we'll have to wait and see, but part of their initial reorganization is to close a number of stores.  Having been back to our last hometown in Colorado last week, one begins to imagine the scenario, for there they have already announced that store's closing.  In this instance, it will leave a town of something like 75,000 people without a retail store aside from a small independent primarily devoted to textbook sales near a college campus.  I'm a great believer in independent book stores, and this one received a great deal of my business when I lived there, but it attracts a small and focused customer base at best.  The real result will be a continued movement towards on-line purchase and ebook purchases.  The only brick and mortar option will be a Barnes and Noble (aside from a B & N on campus where almost no one but students venture) some twenty miles away.  I know this is the inevitable movement of the industry, and I've voiced my qualms of chain book stores before, however, will we all want to move towards electronic books all the time or the environmental expense of warehouse to doorstep delivery as we support one behemoth on-line retailer.  I want a world back with options, one with quirky, independent retailers who know their books and know their community.  Somehow the likely failure of Borders is likely to make my wants more remote rather than more possible.  With every retail collapse, be it a giant or an independent, how many readers does the market lose?

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Book Recommendation: The New Valley

Remember the name Josh Weil.  When he produces a book to follow up his debut collection of three novellas The New Valley (2009), buy it.  Once in a while a new writer comes along who reminds you why you love books, why  books allow you to see people in ways you'd forgotten you could, books even that teach you to question yourself and your preconceptions.  In this beautifully, honestly written novella collection, Weil continuously shows us characters we tend to, at first glance, think that we should dismiss, and in some instances, characters we dearly want to hate.  And then he does the remarkable--he redeems them, or rather, he presents them in the fullness of their humanity and allows us to redeem ourselves.  You'll never see the hill country between the Virginias in quite the same way after reading this book.  He writes himself into situations that seem like they might well prove impossible for a veteran author and then every time he gets it just right.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Book Recommendation: The Lady Matador's Hotel

Christina Garcia's new novel The Lady Matador's Hotel is wonderfully original, employing a cast of six radically different characters whose live cross through their stays at an affluent hotel in an unnamed central American capital.  The novel's structure is complex and original.  The atmosphere of a place in perpetual turmoil is spot-on in its portrayal.  And the narrative, like the character depiction, is energized by occupying some space between realism and Magical realism--an altogether fitting style for the setting, the character's backgrounds, and the events.  You can read reviews and learn more about Garcia through her website. 

Monday, September 27, 2010

"Speak" Latest Victim of Attempted Book Banning

A reminder: September 26th – October 1st is National Banned Books Week. If you live in a school district where those with closed minds are attempting (or have succeeded) to ban books, please take the time to write your newspaper editor or your school board members or your school administrators and speak up against such ignorance and injustice. The latest victim of attempted book banning is Laurie Hals Anderson’s Young Adult novel Speak. She offers details of the idiot behind the attempt to ban the book at her blog, along with links to write on the book’s behalf in Missouri where it is under attack.



I spent twenty years of my life teaching writing and literature at the university level. I can't tell you the number of students I encountered in my career who talked about having read Speak as teenagers and having it become the book that motivated them to want to write. Moreover, many students spoke passionately about how Speak touched their lives and encouraged them to share their voice, to speak out against injustice, and in one case, gave a student who had suffered a similar fate the courage to face her past and speak out against violence.


I have read only a handful of YA books. I read Speak because of these students I mention. I found it eloquent, smart, and respectful of its subject, its characters, and its readers. I remember reading the book in one sitting and feeling I had known some of the people who populate its pages. As the father of three daughters, it is one of the books that I suggested each of them read when they reached their own teenage years.


It is exactly the sort of book that should make all of us speak loudly against ignorance and simple-mindedness, two qualities shared by those who suggest we ban books. To ban books is to ban ideas. It is an affront to freedom and we should speak out against those who try and disperse injustice.

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Read a Bad Book

If I start a writing day by first reading something, I tend to read work that I respect, work that inspires me, that reminds me why writing matters and of the role books can have in our lives. I still subscribe to such a theory and advocate its application. However, after a conversation with my oldest daughter about an ethnography she was assigned early on in a graduate course, I am reminded that there is merit and instruction in doing the opposite—read a BAD book.


Why waste your time, you are inclined to say. Well, one could offer the argument that I recall no lesser writer than William Stafford once made, that reading a bad book can bolster your confidence to write a good one. There is something more, I think. It is something that requires you to read differently, for if you are reading a bad book as part of your writing development, then you must identify, specifically, what makes it so bad. Here you can’t just dismiss opinion or consider your reaction a matter of taste, you really have to identify how and why the book fails in its writing. (Remember, there are books written badly on important and compelling subjects and those who wish earnestly to have value, as well as those that simply offer bad “B” movie treatments of tired, weak-limbed, I’m-not-pretending-not-to-waste-your-time wood pulp destroyers.) You must get analytical and study a bad book with the same intensity the smart writer studies a good book. Once identified, the hard part is not repeating the same errors.


Try this useful exercise the next time you are frustrated, but don’t give it too much time because not only are there droves of good books you need to read, you’ve can’t afford another excuse to delay returning to your own work (remembering that it might just take a great deal of bad writing to ever get to the good stuff).

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Book Lovers, Carbon Footprints, and Moral Dilemmas

Among editors, agents, writers, and others associated in one form or another with the publishing industry, you can’t have a conversation or open a industry journal or blog post without encountering the varying debates on what e-books will do (are doing) to transform the medium of how reading materials are presented to the consumer. Every sort of argument is posted, from the economic impacts, the contractual language of book deals, the future for publishing houses, the role of gatekeepers, to the very structures and contents of books themselves. Forgetting aesthetics, personal preferences, individual fondness (the heft of a good book, the pace of turning real pages, the portability, the possession of a library built over years and years of reading…), e-book technology is here, it is growing exponentially, and it is quickly gaining real aficionados among serious readers and techies alike. For the first time in its history Amazon reported that last month the sales of e-book titles surpassed sales of physical books. According to Eco-Libris, e-reader sales saw a 176.8% increase in 2009. The world moves on. E-books will continue to become a growing presence in the publishing marketplace and likely will one day dominate book sales.


One question often lost in the debates among industry insiders is whether this explosion of e-books is good for the environment. The more studies one reads, the more unclear the answer often is, due in large part to most all of the voices weighing in on such debates having vested interests one way or another on the answer. (In the spirit of disclosure, I must reveal my own interests here, for as a writer, the price-per-item of initial e-book titles vs. physical books will almost certainly reduce my future earnings significantly should e-books outpace physical books.) While likely imperfect, a study put out by the Cleantech Group would seem to indicate that e-books can have substantial positive environmental impact. Their study finds that the carbon footprint of an e-reader (factoring in manufacture, energy use, delivery to consumer, raw materials, etc.) is equivalent to that of 22.5 physical books (which do not use vast quantities of paper but have extremely high transportation costs). There is a good deal of statistical data to weigh through in the full report and a good deal of base point assumptions about the reading habits of those who own e-readers, etc. but their initial findings seem to be generally corroborated elsewhere. Whatever may happen in the commercial market, and we probably would be guilty of mimicking ostriches if we don’t see the inevitability of this growth, e-books hold tremendous economic and environmental savings in large niche markets such as college textbooks (removing the paper waste associated with multiple editions with minimal changes) and medical texts, among others.



What we can know is that the traditional publishing industry hasn’t exactly been environmentally conscious, and only in recent years have major publishing houses made much of any push to increase their use of recycled paper. Even among those publishers who have made such commitments, we’re still talking about 25 – 30% recycled paper usage at best. Estimates vary, but even towards the conservative side, the book publishing industry alone is responsible for the harvest of 30 million trees annually (and this grows explosively once the newspaper and magazine publishers are added).


More hard evidence is needed, for the manufacturers of e-readers aren’t exactly forthcoming on all the component materials that go into the construction of their devices and the environmental impact of those materials. Debates continue; a good beginning place for further investigation is present at Eco-Libris (an organization with its own vested interests we must note) that offers links to a number of related articles about environmental sustainability and carbon footprints in traditional and in electronic publishing. As an aside, I will point out that Eco-Libris may be an organization lovers of physical books want to support, for their mission is to provide readers with easy means to plant trees to offset the physical books they own.


Like most issues, this one gets really complicated, and almost no scenarios for the future seem to bode well for local, independent booksellers or community libraries, to say nothing of emphasizing the quality of book content or the development of a serious literature. At the very least, it is my hope that consumers will become educated such that one of the leading questions they ask as they contemplate the purchase of a product or their participation in an industry is focused on the environmental impact of that decision. If the demographics among frequent book purchasers hold up and we are looking at consumers who tend to be highly educated, frequently urban, and typically upwardly mobile, the trickle-down effect of becoming environmentally educated consumers becomes even more critical. In a consumer culture, like it or not, where we spend our dollars matters a great deal. Our culture needs books. We need good books. And we need intelligent, curious readers. The medium by which we get those good books may mean a great deal to our collective future as well.

(This post also appears on last Wednesday's blog over at Earthstorys.org.)

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

The Bookshelf

I have way too many books.  Shelves and shelves of them and still I use the library every week.  But I have one bookshelf, the one closest to my writing desk, that gets preferential treatment.  Only the books that I love best--a very select few--are housed there.  These are the books I come back to again and again.  Dog-eared, their covers often worn soft from use, they are books I turn to not only out of love but for study.  Some I read parts of virtually every week.  They are joined by the books I need for research at that particular moment, but that purpose is different from the use I make of these--which is something more like carrying photos of the ones you love.  A few titles change from time to time.  More will be added.  But there are a few that will always have a place on that shelf.  Among them:

  • The Collected Poems of Rilke
  • The Times Are Never So Bad by Andre Dubus
  • The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien
  • Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier
  • Joe by Larry Brown
  • Fay by Larry Brown
  • Olive Kittridge by Elizabeth Stout
  • The English Patient by Michael Ondaatje
  • American Primitive by Mary Oliver
  • The Paradise of Bombs by Scott Russell Sanders
Those are some of mine.  What's on your shelf?

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

A World Far From Familiar


In Other Rooms, Other Wonders
Daniyal Mueenudin
W.W. Norton and Company (2009), 247 pp.


Daniyal Mueenudin’s debut title suggests a book that will force readers to step far outside their lives and enter unfamiliar worlds. Indeed perhaps the greatest reward in reading In Other Rooms, Other Wonders is gaining entrance to the largely unfamiliar, nearly dysfunctional world of contemporary Pakistan, a culture so stratified and so deadened to its own corruption that its inner-workings may well fascinate many American readers. Mueenudin, a Pakistani-born, American-educated newcomer on the literary scene, has garnered wide critical praise and a National Book Award nomination for this group of eight linked stories. The book is beautifully written and culturally enlightening, though the stories themselves may often prove to keep American readers too distant from its characters and events and sometimes struggles to bring closure to the individual stories. The characters are well crafted and identifiable, though the patterns of their lives may seem largely alien. The vision granted of the vivid and unflinching portraits of Pakistani culture—from its wealthiest landowners to their lowliest servants—can, for readers interested in places and people beyond their own immediate frame of reference, make up for the lack of closure and the grand scale of the collection.


The stories are all linked in one fashion or another to one of its principle characters, wealthy landowner K.K. Harouni. Whether exploring Harouni himself as his once vast landholdings are slowly sold off to low bidders in the effort to maintain his luxurious lifestyle or centering on the tales of his servants and managers, the linked stories eventually allow readers to recognize that everyone within Pakistan may share similar linkages. These stories are connected by association to Harouni and, more importantly, by themes that focus on bartering and greed and manipulation, by the sexual politics of advancement for women and the power hunger exhibited by those who can touch the fringes of wealth. It is not a collection of stories that assembles to form an alternative sort of novel, rather the stories offer the reader, as the title suggests, glimpses into rooms they have never inhabited. The Pakistan that Mueenudin introduces us to is one where corruption and near chaos exist at every social level, where middle managers skim profits from their employers, women attempt to sleep their way off village streets and into the manor house, where the educated and the powerful are often bored and harm themselves and others by their attempts to resolve boredom, and the peasants often mimic the wealthy they serve. While the stories sometimes fail to complete a storytelling arc that is comforting to American readers, the characters and their sometimes desperate measure to better their living conditions prove fascinating and likely universal. For literary readers who recognize the role essential elements of Pakistani culture will play in the West’s inevitable future interdependency within Pakistani politics, the book can prove particularly fulfilling.

Mueenudin sees his own culture with astonishing clarity (the author has returned to Pakistan after earning degrees from Dartmouth and Yale to run a family farm). Importantly, he refuses to be overtly charitable nor chastising with any of his characters. Nearly all seem deeply flawed individuals, characters whose very flaws may arise either from the expected “back-scratching” reality of their deeply stratified culture or by elemental human envy and desire for advancement. The tale Mueenudin tells is larger than any of these individual characters, larger than Harouni, larger perhaps even than Pakistan. While some Western readers may feel kept at arm’s length from the events that unfold, they will find themselves thinking about the world Mueenudin portrays long after they close the final story.

Friday, September 4, 2009

Parallelism

I've been thinking a great deal lately about the role of parallelism in literature, the way that in good work it can be as if we've entered a hall of mirrors, a hall of mirrors erected at angles and cantered by varying degrees such that images reflect back on themselves although never in a direct line, never a simple exact duplicate. This is how jazz works differently than pop music where you can hear the recurrent theme but it never repeats precisely, instead the theme gets reborn again and again in new variations. In pop you get simply, overt repetition of the theme--catchy, sing-worthy, but predictable on many levels. Good books work more like jazz. Sometimes they do so at the largest levels of construction and sometimes only in the most nuanced bits of metaphor and image. The best books often do both.

Perhaps I've been thinking about this so much lately because I am nearing the end of the first draft of a new novel. Frequently on a given day I am writing new material in the morning, material that is creeping up on the awareness that it is pushing near the ending, and by late morning or early afternoon I am either typing material or editing material (more often both--well always both as I type) that was originally written months ago. This constant forward backward movement allows me to look at the earliest passages of the book from the distance of some hindsight (and a new awareness of where the story actually goes) and to see in the newest material the moments when it best reflects the language, tone, images, and rhythms of its origins. Of course this allows me to see, and I hope, capitalize more fully on the echoes and parallelisms that are organically present in the text. That's how it is for me: discovering what has occurred organically at the rather subconscious phase of the original writing and then stepping away into the analytical ability to see in it what is natural what works, and then, with luck, enhance that.

The presence of such development was made material for me the other night when my wife and I were watching a commentary from the writers and directors of "The West Wing" about an episode titled "Two Cathedrals." (Okay, I am rarely a fan of TV, and the series is now years removed, but we are rapid fans of this show; one of those rare shows that is powerfully and smartly written, beautifully directed, and brilliantly acted--why aren't there more?) The writer and director spoke at length about the way they began to envision the use of the convergence of two story lines and the employment of the past and the present through the parallelism of events and of settings. Employing parallelism, symbolism, repeated image and gesture and parallelism in dialogue lines, they move the viewer seamlessly in time, going so far as to trust the viewer enough to be intelligent enough to catch more nuanced points of time transition (something TV rarely does--trust the intelligence of its audience). Beyond employing parallelism in time, they also used these patterns to allow the personal life of the President to reflect the political and executive decisions he encountered, which is one of the very things that drew viewers to the series in the first place, the humanization of a fictional equivalent of those in power from whom we are so otherwise removed and yet so dependent upon. Is that not one of the roles of literature after all, to humanize and activate ideas and experiences that otherwise seem removed and too large in scope to comprehend.

About the same time as seeing this commentary I was finishing my reading of an older Stewart O'Nam novel The Names of the Dead. Now O'Nam is consistently an enviable craftsman, someone whose work I not only enjoy but learn from. He uses parallelism in both plot and image to do something similar and move the reader within two time periods--past and present. Given that Larry Markham, his protagonist suffers PTSD from his service as a medic in Vietnam, the creation of the reader's ability to inhabit the two time periods is critical, for of course Larry does, as do all people who have survived horrific and traumatic circumstances. Memory does not leave. Indeed science shows us that without biological manipulation, the memory of absolute fear cannot leave. The reader must experience this in order to begin to formulate and understanding of Larry's present. The fluidity with which O'Nam transitions such movement in time is precisely the sort of thing writers must study if they are to learn the larger elements of craft.

Of course literature can succeed with employing identifiable applications of parallelism in part because life does. We often fail to see the images and symbols and interweaving lines of such parallelism in our lives simply because our lives are to close to see in focus. Literature allows us to examine such structures and to ask why they exist, to examine what they reveal. As always, when we encounter such applications in good books, we examine our lives and our world anew as well.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

One Hurdle into Another

So, you're writing a novel. You've been writing the novel for months. You meet the book every day, first thing in the morning. It waits for you. On good days it is friendly and talks to you. You start to feel the characters in the room. Some days the writing soars, some days it slogs along, its feet stuck in the muck at the swamp bottom. It's the typical stuff of writing a novel. Each day goes by and more pages are full of ink, and if you're lucky, with each day you begin to see a bit further ahead, begin to see scenes, however murky, images in sepia and a bit out of focus, like E.L. Doctorow says when he talks about writing being like driving at night with the headlights on; you can't always see everything around you, but if you pay close enough attention you can reach your destination. As the story begins to unfold and more scenes become visible to you, the horizon seems a little closer.

Eventually, as happened to me this week, I reached a scene that I've been writing towards for months, a scene that offers a critical turning point in the novel. It occurs more than two hundred pages into the novel. It is a scene I've seen vaguely for months, the exposure of a character's past that is pivotal to the novel. In this case, it is a scene that stands at the apex of the rising action, so I have approached it like a climber, and like a climber, I hope the way down off this summit is an easier route than the way up. I want to think it will be, for the flat lands beyond should be visible now, right?

I finished the scene after many days of work on it with elation. Like all writing worth reading, it will need work still. A great deal of work. But essentially the scene feels as if it has accomplished what I had hoped for. The drafted scene felt fulfilling. It seemed to move the characters into a space in which they were comfortable and established the past I had in mind in a way that felt organic and believable.

The elation lasted about twenty four hours. Then came the realization (as if this should have been any kind of surprise) that I had no real idea what happened next, no real ideal of how these characters will resolve their lives. If this surprises you, it holds no such surprise for me. This is the nature of how I work. The further into the text I am, the more I've learned about it and its direction, but at best the full story appears rather like a Polaroid developing out of the haze. In this instance I've reached a critical moment alongside my characters, but there is more story of course. So I go back to work. I listen for their voices. I try not to panic. I return to that strange but wonderfully satisfying place of semi-consciousness where fiction happens most often for me, so focused on the novel that it begins to mix and distort with actual life at times and writing seems a sort of perpetual dream state. I hang on to the shadows of the larger book, the blurry horizon of its potential ending, the abstractions of what the characters need to accomplish in their lives. From these abstractions I scan for the detailed scenes that will give them motion and voice and possibility, and I wait. I write more and I wait more. I watch for shape. I watch for scenes that begin to form in my subconsciousness. I read backward and I write forward and listen.

I would be lying if I failed to admit that such moments scare me a great deal. There are days when I fully believe I will never find the next word, let alone the next scene or the book's ending. It has been a week full of such days where writing a paragraph takes exhausting effort and the result still looks like it has been insulted with an autopsy. I long for the days when the writing takes control and I turn pages of new material one after another. This must be something parallel to how the bipolar patient feels all of his life. Still, the only answer I know with certainly is that it is time to go back upstairs and work some more. Find the next word and trust that it leads to one after that. If these are characters worth asking someone to share their lives with, then I must trust them to offer direction, for if they are written with real integrity, they will reveal the next events their lives hold.

Friday, April 24, 2009

New Books of Note

Murray Edwards, an editing client of mine through my business theWORDwright (http://www.thewordwright.net/), has recently published a new collection of short stories. Looking for Lucy Gilligan is a wonderfully quirky collection that is often laugh-out-loud funny, sometimes irreverent, and still manages to prove frequently touching. Don't be fooled by Edwards' dry humor, for he proves a sensitive writer, one who paints portraits of complex, concrete characters unafraid of showing the world themselves as they really are. It is a rewarding first collection. The book offers a wonderful individualized vision of contemporary Texas. Visit the website for the book at http://www.lucygilligan.com/.

Another recent book of interest that is receiving very good reviews is the true story of a Nazi concentration camp survivor. I am biased on this one, I must admit, for the author is an old college friend--Von Petersen--and I had the pleasure of reading the book while it was still in manuscript. Carl's Story: The Persistence of Hope is a moving true account of one man's unlikely survival of the Nazi horror and of the time he endured at three of the infamous Nazi camps. The book is extremely compelling and an edge-of-the-seat adventure ride of narrow escapes, happen-chance salvation, and enduring hope. It is an important book about commonplace heroism and stoicism. The author and its subject were recently interviewed on NPR, and the book has been well-received by notable authors who have written on the Holocaust. It is available at http://amazon.com/.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Endless Revision

For years as a teacher I preached that so much of writing was really rewriting, that revision literally often meant re-seeing a text. How true that remains. Water Cycle is a book that has taken years and years to write, in large part because I had to learn how to write a book, and in large part because I chose a project (perhaps purposefully, perhaps to impose self-punishment) that is intricate, complicated, layered. I've spent the last three or four days not just revisiting a text that most would feel is complete, but working on one more short chapter that might help relieve an itch that has always existed, a need to have one of the dead characters in the book have a chance at touching the reader from beyond the grave. It is a revision that is a response both to a need I have always felt but never been able to articulate and a reaction to my interpretation of what several agents have been quietly indicating. Mostly this latest revision comes with a thank you to a quality reader who (my youngest daughter) who not only proved a close, and capable reader, but one willing to take me seriously when I asked her questions. 18 and about to leave for college, the quality of her reading reminds me again of why we must never dismiss the young just because they are young, and why we can always sustain hope for our future. Sometime a reader can offer you just the right prompt to make you ask questions of yourself and then return to instincts on how you respond to those questions. Ultimately good revision can be as fulfilling as the initial creative act, for you begin to see the deeper textures, the veins and sinew running within a text that fuel it and hold it together. In the end the focus remains on finding the way to tell all the story as it wishes and needs to be told. It's just that sometime it takes years to listen to the story.